by Yevgeniy Fiks
Non-contradiction
I will begin with two different descriptions of the state of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union -- one from the left and another from the right on the political spectrum.
The first statement comes from Leon Trotsky's 1936 book "The Revolution Betrayed," where among many points of criticism of Stalin's regime, Trotsky introduced his fierce critique of the state of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union and Stalin's policies in regards to Party life. According to Trotsky, Stalin stroke a fatal blow to the CPSU by easing admission into the Party, which resulted in tens of thousands petit-bourgeois and ideologically-immature workers joining the Party ranks, and as a result, dramatically weakening it. Trotsky viewed this policy of "democratization" of admission into the Party as a fundamentally counterrevolutionary act. Trotsky stated that Stalin, a grave-digger of the Revolution and a petit bourgeois himself, purposely opened up and simplified admission procedures into the Party for general population in order to neutralize the Party's revolutionary potential by bringing in a very large unprepared and/or indifferent to the Revolutionary cause element into the Party ranks.
According to Trotsky, by mid 1920s the true Communists were in the minority in the Party. The Communist Party of the Soviet Union was no longer a revolutionary party, but a convenient tool in the hands of Stalin's bureaucracy. By then, CPSU was no longer the party of Lenin, Trotsky assures us. And from his forced exile and shortly before his violent death in 1940 from the hands of Stalin's henchman, Trotsky longs for the old Party, which was a small and highly ideologically-mature group of advanced working class -- a party, admission to which before the Revolution was no trivial matter.
Non-contradiction
I will begin with two different descriptions of the state of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union -- one from the left and another from the right on the political spectrum.
The first statement comes from Leon Trotsky's 1936 book "The Revolution Betrayed," where among many points of criticism of Stalin's regime, Trotsky introduced his fierce critique of the state of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union and Stalin's policies in regards to Party life. According to Trotsky, Stalin stroke a fatal blow to the CPSU by easing admission into the Party, which resulted in tens of thousands petit-bourgeois and ideologically-immature workers joining the Party ranks, and as a result, dramatically weakening it. Trotsky viewed this policy of "democratization" of admission into the Party as a fundamentally counterrevolutionary act. Trotsky stated that Stalin, a grave-digger of the Revolution and a petit bourgeois himself, purposely opened up and simplified admission procedures into the Party for general population in order to neutralize the Party's revolutionary potential by bringing in a very large unprepared and/or indifferent to the Revolutionary cause element into the Party ranks.
According to Trotsky, by mid 1920s the true Communists were in the minority in the Party. The Communist Party of the Soviet Union was no longer a revolutionary party, but a convenient tool in the hands of Stalin's bureaucracy. By then, CPSU was no longer the party of Lenin, Trotsky assures us. And from his forced exile and shortly before his violent death in 1940 from the hands of Stalin's henchman, Trotsky longs for the old Party, which was a small and highly ideologically-mature group of advanced working class -- a party, admission to which before the Revolution was no trivial matter.
